This insert packs in all of Deep Regrets along with every expansion, in the base box, with no lid-lift. Fourteen card trays keep everything organized on and off the boards, and player bins make hand-out fast, since everything is already sorted before you sit down to play.
Compatibility
Fits Expansions: Yes Compatible with Even Deeper Regrets, the Lamentable Tentacles Mini-Expansion, and the Kickstarter Promo Cards.
Sleeved Cards: No There isn't enough space in the box for sleeved cards.
Organization Notes
You can keep your base and expansion cards sorted separately or mix them together. Each Ocean Depth tray holds 13 cards, which lines up with setup, so you can load either the base or Even Deeper Regrets cards there, or a mix of both. The rest of the cards fit in the other stand-alone trays, and mini-expansion cards, or whatever's left over, go in the Misc Card Tray along with the player aids. If you'd like to keep the Regret, Rod, Reel, and Supply cards separated by base or expansion, try keeping one set upside down in the tray so they're easy to tell apart. I didn't make space for the score pads since I don't play solo or co-op, I laminate one of each and keep them in the box, which adds about 5mm of lid-lift that shrinks as you use up the pads. When loading the player bins, put the ship and life preserver in side-by-side first, then the dice and cube, it's a tight fit but it works. The Clout and Dice come out of their bags and store in the Misc Bin with the first player token, since there isn't room otherwise. The dark blue trays that hold the base and expansion ocean cards double as discard trays during play, and there's an optional divider for the Misc Card tray if you'd like a bit more organization there.
The whole insert in one color: white, gray, black, beige or brown. Our quickest option and the best value.
Colored as shown
Exactly like the photos, with every tray in its pictured color. It costs more because it uses more colors and more hands-on time. Learn more
Custom color
Pick any of 50 shades in a regular or matte finish. Custom colors take a little longer to make and can’t be changed once your order is placed.
Good to know
Made to order
Every insert is made after you order it, just for you in the colors you want. Most orders ship in 3–5 business days.
Check your game
Double check that your game matches the photos exactly. If any components still don’t fit, we’ll do what we can to make it right. Learn more
Free shipping
On orders of $150 or more. Otherwise, we’ll get you the cheapest shipping rate possible.
We’re not affiliated with or endorsed by the game’s publisher. Game names and trademarks belong to their owners and are used only to describe compatibility.
What they're saying
1 / 5
“
Great for allowing all of the expansions to fit in the base box AND make setup and gameplay easier!!!
PPaul P@waymorefunner · Aug 24, 2026
“
You are a wizard... fit like a glove.
JJokerXgg@jokerxgg · Jun 11, 2026
“
once again you nail this out of the park.
SSuperdmz@user_4089203405 · Jun 15, 2026
“
Lovely, tight design. Thanks for developing this!!!!
DDan and Zeb@dan_and_zeb · Jun 22, 2026
“
Love this game and love your inserts
DDwayne@xDwayne · Jun 15, 2026
Choosing a selection results in a full page refresh.